BMW 3 Series
Across six launch reviews, the most-praised new 3 Series turns out to ride on the old car's platform, and the electric one can't get its seat down low enough.

BMW arrived at the launch insisting its petrol and electric cars add up to a single 3 Series, and What Car? relayed the message untested. Six reviews later, the claim has worn thin. The M350 rides on a reworked version of the outgoing G20's platform, while the i3 gets the new Neue Klasse architecture and a battery under the floor. Same face, same badge, and two different answers to what a 3 Series should be.
The strongest case in this slate of reviews belongs to the petrol car. Timed by Joe Achilles, the M350 ran to 60 mph in 3.65 seconds, "Audi RS5 territory," and he rates it a better overall package than the RS5, even the current M5. Underneath sits the outgoing car, reskinned and retrimmed, still carrying the B58 six and ZF eight-speed he calls "the best engine and gearbox recipe on the market." The cost shows up on the scales: 1,935 kg, nearly 200 more than the M340i on the same hardware, a gap he can't account for. What Car? found that chassis firm but composed, with no body lean through fast corners.
The seat gives the i3 away. Driving it back to back with a 1978 E21 323i, CAR magazine found the i3's seat sits "a whole inches higher" than the low perch every 3 Series since the E21 has offered, a striking admission from the magazine that named the i3 its Car of the Year. In the back, Chasing Cars and Autogefuhl both describe passengers whose legs lift clear of the cushion, splayed for support. A week with the car let AutoTopNL feel the height on the road too, high and comfort-tuned, "a bit too too comfortable, too too loosey-goosey." Steering, brakes and throttle passed as BMW; the handling, by his account, did not.
Neither of the reviewers who drove both cars back to back writes the i3 off. Chasing Cars counts it among "the best driver's EVs on the market," playful and rear-biased, with BMW's new Heart of Joy controller keeping stability interventions to a minimum, and Autogefuhl found it quicker than the M350 in real driving. Both still give the drive to the petrol car. Autogefuhl ranks the M350 among the best driver's cars on sale, and Chasing Cars, though it scores the two closely, describes the combustion car as "the car the A-team still works on."
I've been reliably informed by BMW that there is only one 3 Series.
the new 3 Series, excluding the new i3, is essentially a cloaked version of the outgoing G20 3 Series.
it's not a 3 series driving position, it's not quite right.
I'm not sold, and that's just because it does not feel like this is what a BMW should drive like to me.
I would pick a combustion engine 3 Series just from the pure driving pleasure.
you don't need to feel like you're getting second best.
6 reviewers. 3 questions. Where the arguments overlap and where they diverge.
BMW's single 3 Series holds up only on paper. On the road, the best of the new range rides on the outgoing G20's bones, while the purpose-built i3 drives well and still can't put its driver where a 3 Series always has. Even its ride divides the panel: CAR found it plush, AutoTopNL floaty, Autogefuhl booming on passive dampers, and BMW brought no adaptive-damper i3 to the international launch to settle it. The electric car earns its place in the range. It hasn't yet earned the name.
Same name, same face, but only the petrol car still sits like a 3 Series.