BMW M5
The original super-sedan — V8, V10, and back to V8 hybrid.
4 reviewers · 10 videos · 7 press articles
Reviewers strongly agree on its performance and handling, but split on daily drivability.
across 4 reviewers
"Initially, I'm actually surprised at how refined and comfortable the driving experiences here."
TheTopher · ▶ 3:57"Reliability, maintenance, I mean, that's the kicker. That's why these cars have come down in value so much."
Zygrene · ▶ 17:10Performance
5.0/54 of 4 reviewersstrong consensus“It's absolutely insane that BMW put what was essentially a Williams F1 engine into their M5 sedan”
positive · TopherDrives · ▶ 0:41“It truly offered supercar performance and sound from a four-door sedan.”
positive · TheTopher · ▶ 0:29“She is no slouch.”
positive · Jubbal & Cars · ▶ 10:04Handling
4.0/54 of 4 reviewersstrong consensus“You can really feel the heft of this car. We have MacPherson struts, multi-link rear, 4,000 pounds.”
mixed · Jubbal & Cars · ▶ 6:15“Beautifully smooth steering. It's silky. It's actually like a lightness to this that I really wasn't expecting.”
positive · TopherDrives · ▶ 14:58“The steering is light, but it has decent feedback or reminds me a bit of the E90 M3, but not as good in terms of the feedback.”
mixed · Zygrene · ▶ 8:52Fun to drive
4.5/54 of 4 reviewersstrong consensus“I've always always always wanted to drive a V10 M5 and I've always wanted to own one of these cars too”
positive · TopherDrives · ▶ 39:06“One of my favorite BMWs I've ever driven. Just phenomenal.”
positive · TheTopher · ▶ 12:31“Beautiful engine, really happy to rev out.”
positive · Jubbal & Cars · ▶ 5:07Daily drivability
3.5/54 of 4 reviewerssplit“Initially, I'm actually surprised at how refined and comfortable the driving experiences here.”
positive · TheTopher · ▶ 3:57“It's smooth. It's easy. It's quiet. It's relaxing.”
positive · TopherDrives · ▶ 30:45“Reliability, maintenance, I mean, that's the kicker. That's why these cars have come down in value so much.”
critical · Zygrene · ▶ 17:10Value
3.5/54 of 4 reviewersconsensus“Market value for these cars in the US between $15 and $30,000 for most decent examples.”
positive · Zygrene · ▶ 3:27“And at 15 to 30,000 dollars, I mean, it's hard to beat.”
positive · Jubbal & Cars · ▶ 10:47“you're probably going to be spending about $60,000 to have one like this. Now, these cars do exist for like 15 grand, but you're going to be looking at an 80,000 mi SMG car”
mixed · TopherDrives · ▶ 39:23Hear it in the reviewer’s words
- Car and Driver
Driven: 2000 BMW M5 Is a Four-Door German Corvette
◆Worth itThe 2000 M5 is a masterclass in blending high-performance V8 power with the refinement of a luxury executive sedan.
- Best for
- discerning, well-heeled drivers seeking a high-performance daily driver.
- Watch out
- High price point · Potential fuel quality sensitivity due to 11.0:1 compression
Quotes worth your time - MotorTrend
2022 BMW M5 CS vs. Cadillac CT5-V Blackwing, 2021 Mercedes-AMG GT63 S: Supersedan Shootout!
◆Worth itThe BMW M5 CS is the unanimous winner, offering the best balance of performance, handling, and driver engagement.
- Best for
- Enthusiasts seeking the ultimate high-performance sport sedan experience.
- Watch out
- thick steering wheel · complex interface · transmission programming · lack of emotional connection
2,388 wordsOpen articleQuotes worth your time - Road & Track
2022 BMW M5 CS On-Track Video Review: the M5 at Its Best
◆Worth itThe M5 CS is a masterclass in tuning that proves the M5 platform can be truly involving and pure.
- Best for
- Enthusiasts who want a high-performance family sedan that doesn't sacrifice driver engagement.
- Watch out
- No center console storage · Center piece of bucket seats can be annoying
586 wordsOpen articleQuotes worth your time







